Page 1 of 2
Top 10 Comic Movies
PostedTue Jun 21, 2005 7:34 pm
by Jerrel
What is you top 10 favorit comic book movies. Include any movie that was a comic first it doesn't have to be superheroes also include movies where you're not sure if the movie was a comic before hand but it looks like a comic book movie like Mystery Men
1. Spider Man 2
2. Batman Begins
3. Spider Man
4. Batman
5. Mystery Men
6. Hellboy
7. American Splendor
8. Ghost World
9. Lueage of Extrodinary Gentelmen
10. Sin City
PostedTue Jun 21, 2005 7:53 pm
by Hashum
1. Superman III
2. Spiderman
3. Batman
4. X-Men
5. X-Men II
6. Superman II
7. Batman II
8. Dare Devil
9. Spawn
10. Heavy Metal
Sorry was running out of Movies I'd seen there in the last 3 or so.
PostedTue Jun 21, 2005 8:07 pm
by Sai'nu
1. Spiderman
2. Batman Keaton said it best, "I'm; Batman!"
3. Batman Begins
4. X-men 2
5. Transformers: The Movie
6. G.I.Joe: The Movie
7. Batman Returns ((The 'real' Catwoman... Me~ow!!))
8. Spawn
9. Hellboy
10. Supergirl ((just a little better than Alicia Silverstone as Batgirl))
Re: Top 10 Comic Movies
PostedTue Jun 21, 2005 8:41 pm
by Novall
[quote="Jerrel"]What is you top 10 favorit comic book movies. Include any movie that was a comic first it doesn't have to be superheroes also include movies where you're not sure if the movie was a comic before hand but it looks like a comic book movie like Mystery Men
1. The Punisher
2. The Punisher
3. The Punisher
4. The Punisher
5. The Punisher
6. The Punisher
7. The Punisher
8. The Punisher
9. The Punisher
10. The Punisher
There, fixed it for you. Out of all those movies...this one is definately the most realisticly adapted of them all. Any arguments and I'd say watch it then judge if you havent already.
PostedTue Jun 21, 2005 8:43 pm
by Novall
Sai'nu wrote:
1. Spiderman (crap)
2. Batman Keaton said it best, "I'm; Batman!" (crap)
3. Batman Begins (mega crap)
4. X-men 2 (Crap)
5. Transformers: The Movie (Now this is my kind of movie.)
6. G.I.Joe: The Movie (Again...another awesome movie.)
7. Batman Returns ((The 'real' Catwoman... Me~ow!!)) (crap)
8. Spawn (crap)
9. Hellboy (crap)
10. Supergirl ((just a little better than Alicia Silverstone as Batgirl))
(Hellen Slater is better in The Secret of My Success)
Re: Top 10 Comic Movies
PostedTue Jun 21, 2005 8:44 pm
by Hashum
Novall wrote:Jerrel wrote:What is you top 10 favorit comic book movies. Include any movie that was a comic first it doesn't have to be superheroes also include movies where you're not sure if the movie was a comic before hand but it looks like a comic book movie like Mystery Men
1. The Punisher
2. The Punisher
3. The Punisher
4. The Punisher
5. The Punisher
6. The Punisher
7. The Punisher
8. The Punisher
9. The Punisher
10. The Punisher
There, fixed it for you. Out of all those movies...this one is definately the most realisticly adapted of them all. Any arguments and I'd say watch it then judge if you havent already.
I must assume that you mean the New Punisher movie and not the one with the Soviet from Rocky correct? I haven't seen the new one but that first one was crap.
Re: Top 10 Comic Movies
PostedTue Jun 21, 2005 8:45 pm
by Novall
Hashum wrote:Novall wrote:Jerrel wrote:What is you top 10 favorit comic book movies. Include any movie that was a comic first it doesn't have to be superheroes also include movies where you're not sure if the movie was a comic before hand but it looks like a comic book movie like Mystery Men
1. The Punisher
2. The Punisher
3. The Punisher
4. The Punisher
5. The Punisher
6. The Punisher
7. The Punisher
8. The Punisher
9. The Punisher
10. The Punisher
There, fixed it for you. Out of all those movies...this one is definately the most realisticly adapted of them all. Any arguments and I'd say watch it then judge if you havent already.
I must assume that you mean the New Punisher movie and not the one with the Soviet from Rocky correct? I haven't seen the new one but that first one was crap.
Yes the new one. OMG you havent seen it? Dude! rent it NOW! I have the Dolph Lundgren Punisher also...and yes it was crap. Honestly though, Dolph make a better comic-book adapted Punisher then Tom Jane did.
PostedTue Jun 21, 2005 8:49 pm
by Sai'nu
I refer to Dolph as 'Old Chicken Lips' because of that adaptation. You know, where he's standing on that pool table or whatever it was spraying away with that big old machine gun and his lips are just pursed in a way that makes ya wanna laugh at'em.
However, your right, Dolph made the better Punisher. However the 'new' Punisher had the better story I thought.
Mmmm.. Secret of my Success. Good movie too.
And, note, amongst my crap; There 'were' some Novy approved titles!
PostedTue Jun 21, 2005 9:38 pm
by Zyre Mercutio
1) Spider-Man
2) X-Men
3) Batman
4) X2
5) The Crow
6) Superman II
7) Men in Black
8) Blade
9) Rocketeer
10 Road to Perdition
But I have not seen Constantine, Batmen Begins, or Sin City yet so they are now factored into my rankings.
Zzzzzz
PostedTue Jun 21, 2005 9:48 pm
by Kyanus
1. Batman
2. Sin City
3. Batman Begins
4. Blade Runner (I just have to consider this one)
5. Superman II
6. X-Men
7. Spider-Man
8. Blade
9. Transformers: The Movie
10. G.I. Joe: The Movie
Man, the hardest part of this is trying to order them all.
PostedTue Jun 21, 2005 10:18 pm
by Sai'nu
I guess I did forget one that I liked.... a notable mention at least:
Notable Mention Award goes to... Dick Tracy!
PostedWed Jun 22, 2005 6:20 pm
by Jerrel
Ok have to revise my list. Forgot a few movies like Blade and Punisher.
1. Spider Man 2
2. Batman Begins
3. Blade
4. Punisher
5. Spider Man
6. Batman
7. Mystery Men
8. Hellboy
9. American Splendor (common this had great acting in it)
10. Ghost World (another movie with amazing acting)
PostedWed Jun 22, 2005 6:47 pm
by Seret Sajet
I try to avoid top 10 lists because I find it really hard to rank my favorite films but here's a rough list:
1. Batman Begins
2. Spiderman 2
3. Spiderman
4. X-men
5. X2
6. Blade
7. Hellboy
8. Superman
9. The Punisher
10. The Crow
I have to give honorable mention to Constantine, Ghost World, From Hell, The Crow, Batman, and Daredevil.
Personally I felt Spawn, Supergirl (c'mon they climb a freakin' mountain to get out of the Phantom Zone), and League of Extrodinary Gentlemen were pure crap in my book. Thats just me though.
American Splendor was a great film but I don't know if I'd consider it a "comic book movie" like the rest. Its more about the guy behind the comic (even though the comic was about him) much like Crumb was. Both very, very good films though. Its not a comic adaptation though.
I also haven't seen Sin City but I'm guessing that will make the list.
PostedWed Jun 22, 2005 6:47 pm
by warsloth
I have to second Novall's list, I like the spidey movies too though.
I actually thought the new guy looks more like the punisher, at least in my mind. The poster I have on my wall looks just like him (comic poster)
He's holding a smoking M-16 "masterkey" Props to anyone who knows the config of the masterkey without google, or asking Zannon... I myself prefer the m16+m203 config.
PostedWed Jun 22, 2005 7:55 pm
by Jerrel
warsloth wrote:I have to second Novall's list, I like the spidey movies too though.
I actually thought the new guy looks more like the punisher, at least in my mind. The poster I have on my wall looks just like him (comic poster)
He's holding a smoking M-16 "masterkey" Props to anyone who knows the config of the masterkey without google, or asking Zannon... I myself prefer the m16+m203 config.
Thats because the artist worked from a photo that he took of the guy. I cannot remember the artist name for the life of me but he loves to take pitures of real people in posses he wants to use for his covers and works from those to create a very real but very comic (I would accually use graphic novel) art style feel to his work.