Page 1 of 2
ToOW gets a 50% in PC Gamer this month...
PostedTue Dec 06, 2005 12:09 pm
by Novall
ToonTown Online got a 53%. heh
PostedTue Dec 06, 2005 1:51 pm
by Sai'nu
At this point... that doesn't really surprise me. Everyone is going to rip them a new one straight on into the New Year because of how they pushed a game changing patch on an unsuspecting community. I doubt we'll ever see SWG get a good review again.
/shrug
No matter how big the company, or the person, you can't change the past though. In all do fairness I would hope that number could change into a good one... someday. I'll be around to find out for one.
I'm sorry, but I am going to keep a possitive attitude around here about SWG even if it pisses everyone else off. A lot of the changes really are good; just not well thought out yet (and still being worked on) and putting us back into alpha/beta testing. Should we be at this point? No. But for the sake of the Star Wars name I know and love; I'm going to continue to give it a chance. And while an already old game... I think this kind of newness should have the potential to prolong the shelf-life of a game for extended years.
Although I find any insider information to be completely bogus... I'd lean toward seeing what the game looks like in six months if you still happen to be one of the ones that simply hates it and can not trust SOE/LA PR right now.
PostedTue Dec 06, 2005 2:25 pm
by Jabe Adaks
I'm having a blast since the rebalance. I just wish PvP was still as fun.
Jabe
PostedTue Dec 06, 2005 3:06 pm
by Zannon
Personally, I think ToOW is a lot better than RotW, I haven't done half as many quest in RotW as I have in ToOW...the loot is better, the stories are better, and the variety of things you have to do in the quests are better.
PostedTue Dec 06, 2005 3:37 pm
by Jabe Adaks
Zannon wrote:Personally, I think ToOW is a lot better than RotW, I haven't done half as many quest in RotW as I have in ToOW...the loot is better, the stories are better, and the variety of things you have to do in the quests are better.
/agree
I still have a ton of Kashyyyk quests to do and have no inclination to do them.
Jabe
PostedTue Dec 06, 2005 4:34 pm
by toront
Yeah, ToOW was an awesome expansion. After a week of doing the quests and being real into the repeatable dungeons and generally thinking "this game is really getting fun again", they dropped the bomb.
The expansion = fun
The NGE = crap
PostedTue Dec 06, 2005 6:31 pm
by Revis Xizi
toront wrote:Yeah, ToOW was an awesome expansion. After a week of doing the quests and being real into the repeatable dungeons and generally thinking "this game is really getting fun again", they dropped the bomb.
The expansion = fun
The NGE = crap
QFE
PostedTue Dec 06, 2005 7:52 pm
by Jabe Adaks
Revis Xizi wrote:toront wrote:Yeah, ToOW was an awesome expansion. After a week of doing the quests and being real into the repeatable dungeons and generally thinking "this game is really getting fun again", they dropped the bomb.
The expansion = fun
The NGE = crap
QFE
QFT
Jabe
haha
PostedWed Dec 07, 2005 12:50 am
by DuoXDuoX
At some point your gonna stop finding ways to turn every hugely negative thing that shows where the games heading into a positive batty lol.
PostedWed Dec 07, 2005 1:13 am
by warsloth
I lost my ability to stay aloft on Star Wars hopes and dreams.
PostedWed Dec 07, 2005 2:02 am
by Sai'nu
On that day, DD, is the day I quit posting on any Star Wars related Site having anything to do with RP. Game mechanics don't make RP; We do!

PostedWed Dec 07, 2005 2:23 am
by Jabe Adaks
Sai'nu wrote:On that day, DD, is the day I quit posting on any Star Wars related Site having anything to do with RP. Game mechanics don't make RP; We do!

When the CU came out you were ready to quit on a daily basis. I am glad you have seen the light. Unfortunately few us have the ability to stomach this last set of changes.
Jabe
PostedWed Dec 07, 2005 2:31 am
by Sai'nu
That's exactly the motivation I do have now and where it stims from now, Jabe. Learning from my previous mistake. The game has changed... but it's still playable and it's still fun... because I choose to make it that way for myself instead of beating on it on a daily basis like I was dead set on doing with the CU.
/rant off

haha
PostedThu Dec 08, 2005 5:51 pm
by DuoXDuoX
It still got a lower rating than toon town lol. No rationalizing that lol sorry.
Re: haha
PostedFri Dec 09, 2005 1:44 am
by Isleh
DuoXDuoX wrote:It still got a lower rating than toon town lol. No rationalizing that lol sorry.
Is there an online version of the review?
As far as the quests go? I like them. Some of the NPCs add life and just don't just stand there. Tumbs up.
As far as the graphics go? I hate them. There are some really cool things, the lava waterfalls are pretty amazing. Just gets ruined whan you look at the large lava pools suuounding them. Checkerboards?! After seeing some of the intro movies and cut scene's for other games and viewing the one for Mustafar? SOE gets a big fat thumbs down for that.
So the Isleh review also gives ToOW a 50%