SWG Tales

What do you mean? Free reign?

It means that Lucas is in charge in the end and can tell you how things will happen in his universe. So the author has little control over what can happen to characters in his stories.

Keer wrote:

Hashum wrote:I just have to point out how annoyed I am that R.A. Salvatore couldn't kill off one of his own fantasy characters so came over to Star Wars and had to wipe Chewie out in a very unwookiee like death.

Agreed. Lame. Though I wouldn't blame Salvatore. Given a more free reign from the publisher, I think Salvatore would have done it slicker. Look at how raw Drizzt is. Given freer reign I think all of the SW books would be alot better.

Normally I would agree with you, although I've enjoyed most of the books I've read but you do have a point in most cases. However if I'm not mistaken when Salvatore decided to do the book he gave Lucas a list of characters because he felt someone needed to die and Lucas picked Chewie as the character Salvatore could kill. From there I think he sort of had a little creative wiggle room on how that would happen.

It's just disappointed because I love his Drizzt books and he's a great writer so I just think he could have done a better job. It's been awhile though since I've ready much of anything besides these forums so I could be getting different scenario's mixed up.

There are two other books I think for the thrawn set and one is Suvivors quest and he has one comming out soon and that is Outbound Flight

Yeah cann't wait for the Outbound Flight story. I met Mr. Zahn at Comi-Con 04 and he signed my Survivors Quest and said that the prequell to the book would answer alot of questions. Considering that all his stuff that he wrote that refered to the prequells time period made the assumtion that there was time between the end of the Clone Wars and the Jedi Purge I wonder how he is going to handle this.

Jerrel wrote:Yeah cann't wait for the Outbound Flight story. I met Mr. Zahn at Comi-Con 04 and he signed my Survivors Quest and said that the prequell to the book would answer alot of questions. Considering that all his stuff that he wrote that refered to the prequells time period made the assumtion that there was time between the end of the Clone Wars and the Jedi Purge I wonder how he is going to handle this.

I doubt this will be a problem, there were 100's of Jedi and order 66 in my opinion would only have been the beginning. Not all Jedi could have been out with Clone Troopers at the time of the order so this would have required a more long term purge.

Hashum wrote:

Jerrel wrote:Yeah cann't wait for the Outbound Flight story. I met Mr. Zahn at Comi-Con 04 and he signed my Survivors Quest and said that the prequell to the book would answer alot of questions. Considering that all his stuff that he wrote that refered to the prequells time period made the assumtion that there was time between the end of the Clone Wars and the Jedi Purge I wonder how he is going to handle this.

I doubt this will be a problem, there were 100's of Jedi and order 66 in my opinion would only have been the beginning. Not all Jedi could have been out with Clone Troopers at the time of the order so this would have required a more long term purge.

Actually in the Thrawn trilogy its stated that the Emperor had conmissioned the Outbound Flight and filled it with some of the most powerful jedi. If this occured after order 66 why would the Emporer put any Jedi on it and why would any jedi go. In the trilogy it also states that Outbound went after the war when the senate didn't have a war to worry about.

Jerrel wrote:

Hashum wrote:

Jerrel wrote:Yeah cann't wait for the Outbound Flight story. I met Mr. Zahn at Comi-Con 04 and he signed my Survivors Quest and said that the prequell to the book would answer alot of questions. Considering that all his stuff that he wrote that refered to the prequells time period made the assumtion that there was time between the end of the Clone Wars and the Jedi Purge I wonder how he is going to handle this.

I doubt this will be a problem, there were 100's of Jedi and order 66 in my opinion would only have been the beginning. Not all Jedi could have been out with Clone Troopers at the time of the order so this would have required a more long term purge.

Actually in the Thrawn trilogy its stated that the Emperor had conmissioned the Outbound Flight and filled it with some of the most powerful jedi. If this occured after order 66 why would the Emporer put any Jedi on it and why would any jedi go. In the trilogy it also states that Outbound went after the war when the senate didn't have a war to worry about.

I haven't read the book, all you said was that it made it sound like the purge took place after the clone wars (or at least part of it) so I was simply saying that were this the case it wouldn't be so far fetched. If there are other factors you failed to mention such as the emperor sending the Jedi after the clone wars then yes that would be a problem.

Hashum wrote:

Jerrel wrote:

Hashum wrote: I doubt this will be a problem, there were 100's of Jedi and order 66 in my opinion would only have been the beginning. Not all Jedi could have been out with Clone Troopers at the time of the order so this would have required a more long term purge.

Actually in the Thrawn trilogy its stated that the Emperor had conmissioned the Outbound Flight and filled it with some of the most powerful jedi. If this occured after order 66 why would the Emporer put any Jedi on it and why would any jedi go. In the trilogy it also states that Outbound went after the war when the senate didn't have a war to worry about.

I haven't read the book, all you said was that it made it sound like the purge took place after the clone wars (or at least part of it) so I was simply saying that were this the case it wouldn't be so far fetched. If there are other factors you failed to mention such as the emperor sending the Jedi after the clone wars then yes that would be a problem.

Sorry I made the assuption that you read the Thrawn trillogy. Its a really good read. It is the frist matterial to metion the Outbound Flight. In these books it is also metioned that there was a short time between the end of the Clone Wars and the Jedi Purge but Lucas threw that out the door with RotS. I'm interested in how, with this change, Zahn is going to handle the Outbound flight. Will he ignore what he wrote, or will he pull a rabilt out of his hat and deal with the inconsistancies?

Yet another reason I felt episode 3 was extremely rushed. He threw too much into it to tie up the loose ends and in my opinion it wasn't done well. I mean as soon as grievious dies the the jedi are all slaughtered or so you would think by the way the movie showed it. The war effectively was over when grevious died. There was no real leadership left for the enemy and conceivably at this point a project could have been launched because there would be no need to have all the Jedi fighting.

Perhaps knowing that Grievious was to be killed, I have no doubt Palpatine forsaw that event, he commishioned the group to head out. There was much confusion at the Temple with many of the masters off fighting battles and he could have snuck it with the group that supposedly went. After all the Jedi Jorus C Baoth or whatever his name is was supposedly a fringer in the ranks to begin with and did things for glory. It would have been a perfect thing for him to undertake without consulting the council. Some of the other books that are clone wars novels also speak of other Jedi who were sentured and on the fringe of the order. In my opinion he could exploit that to show that Palpatine gave these men a mission because their Jedi Masters were neglecting them.

Plenty of ways he can reasonably write his way around Lucas. Lord knows he can out write him storywise.

I read the book, closes up all gaps that I could see at least. I think he had trouble putting it all on the screen and not taking 4-5hrs.

E-bo Obi wrote:Yet another reason I felt episode 3 was extremely rushed. He threw too much into it to tie up the loose ends and in my opinion it wasn't done well. I mean as soon as grievious dies the the jedi are all slaughtered or so you would think by the way the movie showed it. The war effectively was over when grevious died. There was no real leadership left for the enemy and conceivably at this point a project could have been launched because there would be no need to have all the Jedi fighting.

Yeah.. part of the reason I disliked Episode I so much was that I *knew* the cool stuff that needed to be covered would get short changed. I mean.. did we really need to see so much of Anakin as a little boy? Did we need the pod race, jar-jar, etc.?

They could have easily not had Episode I.. and instead made Episodes II and III into 3 movies, covering the important stuff in more detail.